DonkeyHR

DonkeyHR vs Keka

Keka is a well-built product with a real performance-management module and a strong position in the 100-500 employee band. This is the comparison where we win least on features and most on how quickly you can start.

How we write these. We sell against Keka, so treat this page accordingly — but it is written from the same internal battlecard our sales team uses, including the parts that concede ground. Where Keka is better, it says so, and the list of things we do not have yet is the real one rather than a curated one.

The short version

Keka is good, and this is not a page where we can claim they are dated or thin — they are neither. They have performance management, which we do not and have explicitly decided not to build in version one, and they are strong in exactly the segment we are climbing into. What we compete on is the buying process: our prices are published, our trial needs no card and no call, and a company under fifty people can be running real payroll the same afternoon. Larger Keka deals go through a demo-gated sales process, which is slower to start whether or not it ends somewhere better.

Where Keka is genuinely better

A real performance-management module

Goals, reviews and the surrounding process. We have none of this, and it is an explicit non-goal for our first version rather than something arriving next quarter. If you want performance and payroll from one vendor, Keka has it and we do not.

Deeper attendance and shift handling

Our attendance is mark-and-approve with regularisation, feeding loss of pay into payroll. Rostered shifts, overtime and biometric device integration are second-version work for us. Keka is ahead here.

A track record in the 100-500 employee band

Keka has been serving companies of exactly this size for years and has the references to show for it. We are in our first year and cannot match that, which is a fair thing for a mid-market buyer to weigh heavily.

Product polish

Keka's UX is genuinely good. Unlike some comparisons in this category, we do not win on interface quality by default and would rather say so than imply otherwise.

Where we are better

You can start today, without a sales cycle

Published per-employee pricing, a 14-day trial with no card, and a company under fifty employees can be running real payroll the same afternoon. Larger Keka deals go through a demo-gated process — if your constraint is that payroll has to work this month, that difference is the whole comparison.

Prices you can see before you talk to anyone

Every tier and per-employee rate is on our pricing page, with the ₹1,499 monthly minimum stated. Keka's pricing is not transparent at scale, so a serious evaluation starts with a call rather than a number.

Statutory compute you can verify without an account

Our public calculators run on the same engine that produces our customers' payslips — PF, ESI including the contribution-period rule, professional tax by state, TDS across both regimes, and gratuity. You can test our compute on your own edge cases before you speak to a rep, which is not something most vendors in this category let you do.

Correcting a finalised payroll run

A mistake found after a run is closed books against the next period rather than rewriting a locked one — the audit trail stays intact and the payslips you already issued stay true. Both Keka and we handle exit settlement; this is the narrower thing worth asking both of us to demonstrate.

Side by side

 DonkeyHRKeka
India statutory payrollCore productIncluded
Performance managementNot built — a deliberate non-goal for version oneIncluded
Exit and full-and-final settlementIncludedIncluded
AttendanceMark-and-approve with regularisationDeeper — shifts, overtime, biometric
Free tierFree forever, up to 50 employees — attendance, leave, ESSNone
Pricing visibilityPublished per-employee ratesNot transparent at scale
Time to startSame day under 50 employees, no call requiredDemo-gated for larger deals
Verify the compute before buyingPublic calculators on the production engineVia demo
Operating historyFirst yearEstablished in this segment

What we do not have yet

This is the same list our own sales team is told not to oversell. If any of it is your top requirement this year, we are probably not the right answer and would rather you knew now.

  • Performance reviews and OKRs — an explicit non-goal for version one, and Keka's clearest advantage.
  • Native biometric or geofenced attendance, and shift rostering with overtime.
  • Expense claims.
  • A native mobile app. Employee self-service is a responsive web app that works in any mobile browser.
  • Self-serve billing management. Billing is handled manually in our first year.
  • DocuSign-grade e-signature. Letters use typed-name plus one-time-code acknowledgment with an audit trail and a public verification page — reasonable for HR letters under the IT Act, but raise strict e-signature requirements with us before buying.
  • The reference list and operating history a five-year-old product in this segment has.

Which one you should pick

Choose Keka if…

You want performance management and payroll from one vendor; you need shift rostering or biometric attendance; or an established reference list in the 100-500 band is a hard requirement for your buying process.

Choose DonkeyHR if…

Payroll and compliance are the job, performance reviews are not, and you would rather see the price, start a trial and run a real payroll this week than book a demo to begin an evaluation.

Common questions

Is DonkeyHR a good Keka alternative?
If your priority is statutory payroll with a fast, self-serve start, yes. If you want performance management from the same vendor, Keka is the better fit — we have deliberately not built it for version one and will say so on a call rather than take you through an evaluation that ends in disappointment.
How much does Keka cost compared to DonkeyHR?
We publish our per-employee rates and our ₹1,499 monthly minimum in full. Keka's pricing is not transparent at scale, so any rupee-for-rupee comparison depends on the quote you are given — which is itself the difference worth noting.
How quickly can we actually go live?
Under fifty employees, the same day: sign up, import employees, run payroll. Above that, a migration mid-financial-year needs your year-to-date figures carried across correctly or your TDS projection and Form 16 will be wrong, so we would rather scope it on a call than promise you an afternoon.

Check the claim rather than taking it

The part of this page you should not take on trust is the statutory competence, and it is also the easiest part to verify. Our public calculators run on the same engine as our payroll — put a real mid-period ESI case or a four-year-eleven-month gratuity through them and see whether the working holds up. Then do the same with whatever you use today.

Try the statutory calculators

Our pricing is on the pricing page, in full, without a form in front of it. Other comparisons: see all.