DonkeyHR

Old vs new tax regime: how employee choice changes TDS

An employee's regime choice changes salary TDS; collect it in writing, use the new regime by default and review payroll if the choice changes.

DonkeyHR Team · 2026-10-27 · 6 min read

An employee’s tax regime choice changes the basis on which you estimate tax and deduct TDS from salary. Use the new regime unless the employee tells you they prefer the old regime. Collect that preference in writing; if it changes during the tax year, check the current official guidance before changing payroll, then review the tax estimate and TDS already deducted.

Why does the regime choice change salary TDS?

Payroll needs an estimate of the employee’s tax to work out salary TDS. The regime used for that estimate matters because the treatment of some salary components and claims differs.

House rent allowance is an example. Under the new regime, the HRA exemption is not available. Under the old regime, it can be claimed subject to conditions. An employee receiving HRA should therefore not assume that the same exemption applies under both regimes.

That difference does not automatically make the old regime better for everyone receiving HRA. Compare the employee’s position under both regimes using current rules and the information they provide. Do not decide from the salary structure alone.

From April 2026, the Income-tax Act 2025 applies. Use “tax year” in tax declaration forms, employee messages and payroll notes. Check the current notification or official portal for applicable rules rather than copying an older payroll guide.

How should you collect an employee’s choice?

Use a short written declaration that clearly asks which regime the employee wants payroll to use. Keep the choice separate from the supporting information used to estimate tax. A collection of rent documents does not clearly express a regime preference.

Ask employees to respond before your internal payroll cut-off. Explain that this is your processing cut-off, rather than presenting it as a statutory deadline.

Give employees a simple explanation: the new regime is the default, and anyone preferring the old regime should tell payroll explicitly. Avoid asking employees to choose from an unexplained abbreviation.

Your collection checklist can include:

  • Employee name and employee identifier.
  • The tax year to which the declaration relates.
  • An explicit old-regime or new-regime preference.
  • The date the employee submitted the choice.
  • Relevant declaration details and supporting documents for claims being considered.
  • Confirmation that the information reflects the employee’s current position.
  • A clear contact or process for submitting a correction.

Keep the declaration with the payroll record. If you enter it manually, compare the saved payroll setting with the employee’s response before finalising the run.

What should you do when an employee does not respond?

Use the new regime unless the employee tells you they prefer the old regime. Do not carry forward an old preference without checking whether it represents the employee’s choice for the current tax year.

Send a plain reminder explaining what payroll will use if no preference is received. Record whether the setting came from an explicit declaration or the default.

This distinction helps when an employee later asks why their TDS was calculated that way. You can explain the record used, instead of relying on someone’s memory of a conversation.

Avoid guessing a preference from last year’s documents, the employee’s age or what colleagues have chosen.

What if the employee changes their choice during the tax year?

Treat a revised preference as a request that needs checking. Collect it in writing and retain the earlier declaration so the change remains traceable.

Before applying it, check current official guidance on whether and how the revised preference can be used for salary TDS. Do not promise that payroll can accept every change immediately.

If the revision can be applied, review the tax estimate using the relevant information under the revised regime. Then account for TDS already deducted and examine what remains to be deducted through the remaining salary runs.

Also review claims whose treatment changes with the regime. For example, do not leave an HRA exemption in the estimate when applying the new regime.

Explain the resulting payroll effect before the next run where possible. A revised estimate can change later deductions, so an employee should understand why their take-home salary may change. If deductions already exceed the revised estimate, check the permitted treatment rather than assuming payroll can refund the difference.

What could a revised estimate look like?

Illustrative worked example: all amounts and payroll-run counts below are invented to explain the arithmetic. They are not statutory rates, limits or actual tax calculations.

Suppose an employee’s estimated tax under the new regime is Rs 24,000. A comparison using the same employee information produces an estimated tax of Rs 18,000 under the old regime. No slab calculation is shown here.

Assume payroll has already deducted Rs 6,000, and there are six salary runs remaining. Also assume the revised preference can be applied after checking current guidance.

Keeping the new-regime estimate would leave Rs 24,000 minus Rs 6,000, or Rs 18,000. Spread equally across six remaining runs, that is Rs 3,000 per run.

Using the revised old-regime estimate would leave Rs 18,000 minus Rs 6,000, or Rs 12,000. Spread equally across six remaining runs, that is Rs 2,000 per run.

The illustrative difference is Rs 1,000 per remaining run. The point is to compare the remaining amount after accounting for earlier deductions. These figures do not show that the old regime is always cheaper.

Common mistakes

Treating HRA as exempt under both regimes can distort the estimate. Check its treatment against the regime actually being used.

Applying a revised preference without reviewing earlier deductions can produce an incomplete calculation. Review the estimate and deduction history together.

Confusing an internal payroll cut-off with a legal deadline creates unnecessary disputes. Label internal dates clearly and check current notifications for legal requirements.

Leaving employees without an explanation can make a correct payroll change look like an error. Share the reason for a changed deduction in simple language.

FAQ

Can payroll choose the old regime because it appears cheaper?

Ask the employee to state their preference. The new regime is the default unless the employee tells the employer they prefer the old regime. A comparison can help inform that choice.

Does receiving HRA mean the employee gets an exemption?

No. The HRA exemption is unavailable under the new regime. Under the old regime, it can be claimed subject to conditions. Check current rules and relevant supporting information.

Must payroll accept a change immediately?

Do not assume that. Check current official guidance on applying a revised preference to salary TDS. Confirm the payroll treatment before promising an employee a particular deduction.

How can software support this process?

DonkeyHR is an Indian payroll and HR product in beta; it computes TDS in payroll runs, lets employees submit IT declarations through its self-service portal, and offers a free public income-tax calculator that compares both regimes. Keep the employee’s written choice alongside the information used for payroll, and check current official guidance when the choice changes.

Related reading